Confirm first
Confirm the exact room category, seasonal minimum stay, parking arrangements and any resort or destination fees before booking.
Illustrative image
Montauk · Boutique Hotels
Crow’s Nest
Small Lake Montauk property with cottages, seasonal dining and proximity to Ditch Plains.
THE EDITORIAL BRIEF
Choose the address, not only the room.
Use this as a base, then build each day around one nearby town or shoreline rather than crossing the full South Fork repeatedly.
- Town
- Montauk
- Category
- Boutique Hotels
- Price
- $$$$
- Address
- 4 Old West Lake Drive, Montauk, NY 11954
- At a glance
- Restaurant, cottages, lake setting, beach proximity
- Source reviewed
- August 2026 · Official source ↗
BEST FOR
Food loversCouplesNear beachBEFORE YOU BUILD AROUND IT
Three useful planning notes
Time it well
Reserve early for summer weekends and holiday periods; midweek dates generally offer more flexibility.
Keep it local
Use this as a base, then build each day around one nearby town or shoreline rather than crossing the full South Fork repeatedly.
MAKE A DAY OF IT
